Module 1
Practical Skills 1.1
Planning

Planning Experiments

Design experiments, identify variables, and assess risks like a professional physicist

OCR H556
Foundation
2-3 hours

What Planning Skills Are Tested

In OCR written papers, you'll be given a scenario or experiment and asked to plan how you would conduct it. You won't actually perform the experiment, but you need to demonstrate that you understand the method, the variables involved, and potential safety concerns.

Questions typically ask you to:

  • Identify independent, dependent, and control variables
  • Suggest appropriate equipment and justify choices
  • Describe a step-by-step method
  • Explain how to ensure a fair test
  • Identify risks and suggest control measures

💡 Why This Matters for Exams

Planning questions are worth 4-6 marks and appear in Papers 1, 2, and 3. Students often lose marks by: not being specific enough (e.g., saying "use a ruler" instead of "use a metre rule with mm precision"), forgetting control variables, or not explaining why a piece of equipment is suitable.

Core Planning Concepts

1. Writing a Hypothesis

A hypothesis is a testable prediction about the relationship between variables.

Good hypothesis format:
"As [independent variable] increases, [dependent variable] will increase/decrease because..."

Example:
"As the length of a pendulum increases, the time period will increase because T ∝ √L according to the equation T = 2π√(L/g)"

Exam tip: Always link your hypothesis to a physics principle or equation if possible.

2. Identifying Variables

Independent Variable (IV): The variable YOU change

Dependent Variable (DV): The variable YOU measure (responds to the IV)

Control Variables: Everything you keep constant to ensure a fair test

Example - Measuring resistance of a wire:

  • IV: Length of wire (you change this)
  • DV: Current through wire (you measure this with ammeter)
  • Control: Wire material, wire diameter, temperature, voltage

Common mistake: Confusing IV and DV, or forgetting control variables entirely!

3. Choosing Equipment

You must justify WHY you chose each piece of equipment based on:

  • Resolution: Can it measure small enough changes?
  • Range: Can it measure the full range of values?
  • Precision: Does it have enough decimal places/significant figures?

Example:

"Use a digital stopwatch (resolution 0.01s) rather than analog (resolution 0.1-0.5s) to measure the time period of a pendulum because smaller time intervals need greater precision."

Equipment specifications to know:

  • Metre rule: ±0.5mm uncertainty
  • Vernier calipers: ±0.01mm
  • Micrometer: ±0.001mm
  • Digital stopwatch: ±0.01s
  • Protractor: ±0.5°

4. Risk Assessment

For every hazard, identify:

  1. The risk
  2. The severity/likelihood
  3. Control measures

Common hazards in A-Level physics:

Hazard Risk Control
High voltage (>50V) Electric shock Use insulated wires, keep hands dry, emergency cut-off switch
Heavy masses Falling objects, foot injury Wear safety shoes, clamp securely, sand tray underneath
Lasers Eye damage Never look directly at beam, wear laser safety goggles, warning signs
Hot objects Burns Use heat-proof mats, tongs, allow cooling time
Radioactive sources Radiation exposure Use tongs, store in lead-lined box, minimize exposure time, stand behind barrier

Exam format: "State one hazard and one safety precaution for this experiment." [2 marks]

Worked Examples

Example 1: Plan an experiment to determine g using free fall

[8 marks]

Question:

A student wishes to determine the acceleration due to gravity (g) by dropping a steel ball bearing and measuring its time of fall. Plan this experiment.

Model Answer:

**Step 1: Identify variables** - IV: Height (h) from which ball is dropped - DV: Time (t) taken to fall - Control: Same ball bearing, no air resistance (use dense metal ball), same release mechanism **Step 2: Choose equipment** - Metre rule (±0.5mm) - to measure height from ground to bottom of ball - Electronic timer with light gates (±0.001s) OR high-speed camera (±0.01s frame rate) - Steel ball bearing (minimize air resistance) - Electromagnet release mechanism (ensures consistent release, no initial velocity) **Justification:** Light gates give much better precision than a manual stopwatch because t is very small (~0.5s for h=1m) **Step 3: Method** 1. Set up electromagnet at measured height h above light gate 2. Place light gate at h = 0 (ground level) 3. Attach ball to electromagnet, switch on 4. Record height h with metre rule (measure to center of ball) 5. Release ball by switching off electromagnet (v₀ = 0) 6. Light gate records time t when ball breaks beam 7. Repeat 5 times for each height, calculate mean t 8. Repeat for heights from 0.2m to 2.0m in 0.2m intervals **Step 4: Fair test** - Same ball (same mass, same diameter) - Same release method (electromagnet ensures v₀ = 0 every time) - No pushing ball (verify v₀ = 0) **Step 5: Risk assessment** Hazard: Ball may bounce and hit someone Control: Use sand tray to catch ball, stand clear of drop zone **Step 6: Data analysis** Plot graph of h (y-axis) vs t² (x-axis) Equation: h = ½gt² → gradient = ½g → g = 2 × gradient

Mark Scheme:

✓ Identifies IV, DV, and at least 2 control variables [2] ✓ States light gate OR high-speed camera with justification [1] ✓ Describes repeats and averaging [1] ✓ Describes range of heights [1] ✓ Mentions electromagnet for consistent release [1] ✓ Identifies hazard with control measure [1] ✓ Correct graph and method to find g [1]

Example 2: Plan an experiment to measure resistivity of a wire

[7 marks]

Question:

Describe how to determine the resistivity (ρ) of a constantan wire.

Model Answer:

**Variables:** - IV: Length L of wire - DV: Resistance R - Control: Wire diameter d, wire material, temperature **Equipment:** - 1m length of constantan wire on meter rule - Ammeter (0-1A, resolution 0.01A) - Voltmeter (0-5V, resolution 0.01V) - Power supply (0-5V) - Micrometer (±0.001mm) for diameter - Crocodile clips, variable resistor **Method:** 1. Measure diameter d of wire using micrometer at 5 different points, calculate mean d 2. Calculate cross-sectional area: A = π(d/2)² 3. Set up circuit: power supply in series with ammeter, variable resistor, wire 4. Connect voltmeter in parallel across wire 5. Attach crocodile clips to wire at L = 0.10m 6. Close switch, adjust variable resistor to get current ~0.5A 7. Record V and I 8. Calculate R = V/I 9. Repeat for L = 0.20m, 0.30m ... 1.00m 10. Take 3 readings per length, calculate mean R **Fair test:** - Same current each time (use variable resistor) - Same wire (material, diameter) - Allow wire to cool between readings (temperature affects R) **Graph:** Plot R (y-axis) vs L (x-axis) Equation: R = ρL/A → gradient = ρ/A → ρ = gradient × A

Mark Scheme:

✓ Circuit diagram with ammeter in series, voltmeter in parallel [1] ✓ States micrometer for diameter [1] ✓ Multiple diameter measurements and mean [1] ✓ Range of lengths specified [1] ✓ Repeats and averaging [1] ✓ Temperature control mentioned [1] ✓ Correct graph and equation for ρ [1]

Interactive Tool: Variable Identification Tool

Practice identifying independent, dependent, and control variables in different experiments

Features:

  • Presents real OCR exam scenarios
  • Drag-and-drop variables into correct categories
  • Instant feedback with explanations
  • Covers all major practical investigations

🚧 Simulation coming soon • ID: variable-identifier

Exam Practice Questions

Question 1

[1 mark]
Multiple Choice

A student investigates how the extension of a spring varies with applied force. Which of the following is the independent variable?

A: Extension of spring

B: Applied force

C: Spring constant

D: Material of spring

Show Answer & Mark Scheme

Answer:

B

Explanation:

The independent variable is what YOU change. The student applies different forces (B) and measures the resulting extension (dependent variable).

Question 2

[3 marks]
Short Answer

A student plans to investigate the relationship between the angle of a ramp and the acceleration of a trolley. State the independent variable, dependent variable, and two control variables.

Show Answer & Mark Scheme

Answer:

✓ Independent: Angle of ramp [1] ✓ Dependent: Acceleration of trolley [1] ✓ Control: Mass of trolley, surface of ramp, starting position [1]

Question 3

[6 marks]
Extended Response

A student wishes to investigate how the time period T of a simple pendulum depends on its length L. Plan an experiment to test the hypothesis that T ∝ √L. Your answer should include: variables, equipment with justifications, a method, and how to process the data.

Show Answer & Mark Scheme

Answer:

**Variables [1 mark]:** IV: Length L of pendulum (measured from pivot to center of bob) DV: Time period T Control: Same bob mass, same amplitude (<10°), same release method **Equipment [2 marks]:** - Metre rule (±0.5mm) - to measure length L - Digital stopwatch (±0.01s) - to measure time for 10 oscillations - Protractor - to ensure consistent small angle - String and metal bob (point mass approximation) **Method [2 marks]:** 1. Set up pendulum with L = 0.20m (measured to center of bob) 2. Displace bob by 5° (check with protractor), release 3. Time 10 complete oscillations, record total time 4. Calculate T = total time ÷ 10 5. Repeat 3 times, calculate mean T 6. Repeat for L = 0.30m, 0.40m ... 1.00m **Data analysis [1 mark]:** Plot T² (y-axis) vs L (x-axis) If T ∝ √L, then T² ∝ L → straight line through origin Gradient = 4π²/g

Planning Experiments - Key Takeaways

  • Always identify independent, dependent, and control variables clearly
  • Justify equipment choices based on resolution, range, and precision
  • Write specific methods with numerical values and units
  • For every hazard, state the risk AND a control measure
  • Plan to repeat measurements and calculate means to reduce random errors
  • State the range of the independent variable (e.g., 0.2m to 1.0m)
  • Explain how you will ensure a fair test (control variables)
  • Know typical uncertainties: metre rule ±0.5mm, stopwatch ±0.01s